On Small Sample Sizes And Analysts With Way Too Much Free Time
from the people-pay-for-this-research? dept
It's really amazing of the ridiculous claims that come out of supposedly reputable analyst firms. It makes you wonder who actually pays them for their reports, and whether or not they get any actual value out of them. Take, for example, the latest report from analyst firm NPD Group, where someone actually bothered to realize that all of the winners of American Idol happened to be southerners. Yes, the south is now 5 for 5 in providing singing sensations beloved by the voting public. Based on this ridiculously small sample size, and not much else it seems, the NPD Group is claiming this amazing coincidence is actually because Cingular sponsors the show, and Cingular is (conspiracy theory alert!) based in the south! Of course, there's one huge problem in this theory. Beyond the fact that Cingular is (yes, you remember now, don't you?) a nationwide carrier with customers all over the country, the only reason they're sponsoring the event at all is because they ended up with the contract after buying AT&T Wireless a few years back. The first two seasons of the show were actually sponsored by AT&T Wireless -- and Cingular simply inherited the sponsorship deal with the merger. Of course, AT&T Wireless is also a nationwide carrier... but its headquarters were based in Washington. So, if this bizarre theory had any merit, the first two winners should have come from the Pacific Northwest.
Reader Comments (rss)
(Flattened / Threaded)
Joke
That's a complete joke. These people get paid to spout this nonsense?
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Member, we also never went on the moon! If was all a pack of lies!!!
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Too Many Analysts, Too Many Lawyers
It's the same with lawyers, there's too many of them all chasing the same cases. The result - idiotic product liability litigation that does little but line the pockets of the lawyers at the expense of everyone.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Arent Cingular/AT&T the ones that admitted to a voting error in the American Idol contest that just ended? So they rigged it so a Southerner would win and then they could put out this analysis report! I knew!
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
there's an incestuous southerners joke in here somewhere
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
What is American Idol?
I knew there was a reason that I never felt inclined to watch the show... All of my idols came from the British Invasion! ;)
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
American Idol sucks anyway
Seriously, what is the hype surrounding this show? The only episodes worth watching are the auditions and that is for the pure humor content anyway. After that, it's just a bunch of wannabe singers and some ridiculously rude british guy that thinks he's funny, when in fact he looks like a complete moron. In any other professional job, the guy would get fired for that kind of attitude.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
What would they would find
if they looked at where the voters were coming from or where the rest of the singers came from?
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Add Your Comment