RSS
Twitter
Instead Of Filtering, How About Teaching Good Judgment?
from the just-an-idea dept
Whenever we see stories about internet filters in schools, the position taken in the article is often that they must be good, because there's so much "bad stuff" out there. However, that ignores some important points: (1) the bad stuff is still out there, (2) much of it will still get through the filters and (3) the filters often block stuff associated with helping people deal with the "bad stuff." In other words, in blindly believing that filters protect children, it can actually leave them less protected, by having them woefully unprepared when they inevitably come across more dangerous material. The Canadian Press is running one of the first mainstream articles I've seen that makes this clear, noting that, "Filters can't give kids critical thinking and good judgment. We have to teach them those skills." This isn't to say filters should never be used in schools, but those who are using them need to recognize the limitations of those filters -- and recognize that kids need to learn at some point the real risks of what's online. If they're simply told that there is no bad stuff out there, or that filters will protect them, then they won't know how to deal with the bad stuff they eventually do encounter. This doesn't mean to let them go off and surf a wide-open internet, but to have someone (parent, teacher, etc.) who can teach them some degree of skepticism and judgment about what they find online, and to realize that not all of it is good. Then, they can learn how to handle, not hide from, questionable content they come across.
Reader Comments
(Flattened / Threaded)
Excellent thinking...
Very good point of view that stresses value-learning. How can anyone learn to evaluate the good and the bad if the bad is left off the scale? Classes in learning how to weigh the media information one gets, in all media forms—not only the internet—should start at an early age and be a critical part of life's progress. Lends new meaning to "question authority".
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Heard of this brilliant gizmo
Now a part of every tv set. Equivalent is coming to your software and computer soon, unless something heads off the Hatch idiots of the world.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
No Subject Given
Clean kids get sick and die.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Smart kids...
Smart kids seem to get smarter with more independent thinking when they've realized that they can hack what the previous generation puts up...including being able to take out v-chips and circuit boards. It could be the basic challenges of confronting and surmounting obstacles and boundaries that comes with every new generation.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Don't forget that the kids know what is on the web and some (most?) want it at all cost. You are assuming porn might be found by mistake. They will search till they get it. Filter or not.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
FUCK U
yall stupid mother fuckers think that blocking these web pages on school computers are going to keep us safe well yall r fucking out of your mind stupid and there is trouble and crime in this world with or with out computers so its not going to make a difference and porn we are all going to learn anout it well know fact idiots GET OVER IT
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
yes, thank you. My school filter is quite strict, but I think the school is realizing what is happening. They spend all this money on a web filter, and then we just have new proxy everyday. Filters dont work, I wonder what it takes to show the world that.
(reply to this comment) (link to this comment)
Add Your Comment