Reader Comments (rss)

(Flattened / Threaded)

1.  

   The sands of time

   

   dorpus, Dec 21st, 2004 @ 1:44pm

   
   

   The IT industry will become a conservative industry full of extensive legal ramifications, whether it wants to or not. Systemic barriers to change are being created by the day.
   
   

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

2.  

   Yahoo is right

   

   Mikester, Dec 21st, 2004 @ 4:00pm

   
   

   I think I have to side with Yahoo on this one. Although I can empathise with the family, I think the soldiers right to privacy trump their wishes to access his private emails.
   Who says that a person's right to privacy is gone at the time of death? Maybe the soldier didn't want his family to have access to his emails.

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

3.  

   Yahoo!

   

   david, Dec 21st, 2004 @ 5:18pm

   
   

   I think Yahoo is on firm legal ground. Unless the deceased left something in writing -- in a will, I suppose -- leaving the e-mail login/password to a loved one, then it seems that e-mail should remain private. Compare it to, say, a post-office box or safe-deposit box --- just because the owner (renter) passes away, doesn't mean that the parents get ownership, does it? It has to be stipulated in a will, AFAIK.

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

4.  

   Yahoo should be fully supported

   

   mbanbury, Dec 21st, 2004 @ 5:39pm

   
   

   My family, nor any of my friends or relatives have access to my personal email account. That is because it is personal. Its my private correspondance with friends, family, associates and love interests. I am currently serving in Iraq, and if I were to fall, the last thing I would want is my family reading emails between me and my girlfriend. It is likely that any email he intended his family to read, has already been sent to them.

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

5.  

   Re: Yahoo should be fully supported

   

   Pussy, Dec 21st, 2004 @ 9:52pm

   
   

   Exactly… He probably does not want his family reading his email to his girlfriend, or his boyfriend. He likely does not want his wife to read it either.
   
   This is not being overly conservative, this is protecting an individuals right to privacy. Kudos to Yahoo.
   
   

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

6.  

   Re: Yahoo should be fully supported

   

   Anonymous Coward, Dec 22nd, 2004 @ 12:35am

   
   

   not to mention that its hard to prove who the 'real' owner of a mailbox is since many dont use their real names or other personal info when signing up. (which i believe is yahoo's main reason for denying it)

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

7.  

   Re: Yahoo! != safe deposit box

   

   Michael Vilain, Dec 22nd, 2004 @ 3:57am

   
   

   Actually, it's totally legal for a family member to present a death certificate and gain access to a safe deposit box if they have a key. If you're the executor of the estate, you need a signed, notarized document and death certificate to access a safe deposite box if you're not a blood relative.
   
   If I was in this situation, I'd be in court suing Yahoo's collective ass. The Terms of Service contract _ends_ with the deceased's death. I don't see how this is different from a safe deposit box, which is property of the deceased's estate and passes to the family or executor.

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

8.  

   Re: Yahoo! != safe deposit box

   

   Anonymous, Dec 22nd, 2004 @ 6:54am

   
   

   ...access to a safe deposit box if they have a KEY...
   
   Or, say, the PASSWORD?????
   
   Again, unless it is in the will, it does not automatically belong to the family.
   
   Who is the executor in this case?

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

9.  

   Re: Yahoo! == safe deposit box but is email == pro

   

   Michael Vilain, Dec 22nd, 2004 @ 9:43am

   
   

   If I didn't have a key, the signed document stating I'm the executor and death certificate would be enough to force the bank to break into the box.
   
   I don't see how Yahoo! has a legal leg to stand on with this issue as all contracts cease with the passing of the owner of the account. If they destroy property that's part of the estate of a deceased, they're in big trouble. Now, is email property thats inheritable?

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

10.  

    Re: Yahoo! == safe deposit box but is email == pro

    

    Anonymous Coward, Dec 23rd, 2004 @ 10:27am

    
    

    One pays for a safe deposit box.
    One doesn't pay for a free Yahoo email account.
    
    Yahoo is correct on this one.

    [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

11.  

    

    GG, Apr 5th, 2008 @ 7:19pm

    
    

    my sister recently passed away and her death is being investigated as a potential homicide due to the violent nature of her relationship with her BF, who was present when she died.
    
    my family wants access to her Yahoo account so we can pass along emails to/from her BF that may assist the investigation. Yahoo really needs to help us out on this, and i have been searching for answers online as to how to contact Yahoo, info on getting access to a deceased person's email, etc. for days. i know this article is old and my sister's case isn't like this dead marine's, but i really hope Yahoo can help my family by giving us access to her account so we can give the investigators any information that may be in her account that may shed light on the events leading to her death.

    [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

12.  

    

    ryan, Jul 20th, 2009 @ 8:31pm

    
    

    im so surprised that this is not more and more of an issue as time passes since email is such a huge part of our loved ones lives. and so many more ways of holding precious last moments that the family would want to know and share. it could even sum up confusion and help them understand more n what was going on with their lives at, especially an untimely death.
    
    i lost me wife of 35 a week and a half a go. and the last time we spoke the night before she died(i was out of town)she was on yahoo i.m and i was texting through my yahoo account. we i.m.ed each other most of the week when i was away. she always saved her messages in her i.m. i dont remember every word but i do know one of the last things she typed was that she missed me and my son who was with me... all i want is her email password to read those last conversations i had with my wife, mother of my son and the first and only love of my life of 17yrs.
    
    i havent tried to call and tell them my story i can barely type this but if they cant help me i will delete my account of 10 years for good.
    
    the yahoo way:
    
    "No Right of Survivorship and Non-Transferability. You agree that your Yahoo! account is non-transferable and any rights to your Yahoo! ID or contents within your account terminate upon your death. Upon receipt of a copy of a death certificate, your account may be terminated and all contents therein permanently deleted."

    [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

13.  

    Re:

    

    jah, Oct 19th, 2009 @ 3:12pm

    
    

    hey im doing a research paper dealing with this topic and i just wanted to let you know if u havent found out already that Yahoo did give those emails over to the parents it took a court order but it was done. hope you got the emails from your wife before yahoo deleted them

    [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

14.  

    Re:

    

    logarithm (profile), Jan 29th, 2010 @ 12:01pm

    
    

    Legally - can't do in most states. You need to let law enforcement have all the info. They will be able to get access to the account(s) thru search warrants signed by a judge. You don't want to even think about touching those emails - if there's anything there, the evidence will be compromised if you open them with your IP address.

    [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

Add Your Comment