Reader Comments (rss)

(Flattened / Threaded)

1.  

   Safety?

   

   Ed, Sep 4th, 2001 @ 2:58pm

   
   

   More than one laptop maker has had a recall due to some cases of laptop batteries catching fire. It seems like if the ingredients to a fuel cell are in there, the potential danger is higher. In fact, no matter what technology is eventually used, more energy-dense power sources will have a larger potential for nasty consequences in the event of a mishap. Imagine if the typical cell phone had the same potential energy as a big car battery. Dropping one into the tub could make a real mess. At some point I'd even be wary of holding a phone up to my head if it had been dropped on the ground. I hope that safety factors into future designs as power capacities go up.

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

2.  

   Seems safe to me

   

   Phillip Temple, Sep 4th, 2001 @ 8:04pm

   
   

   Fuel cells can use pretty much anything as an 'ingredient' (or fuel source). From hydrogen to propane, methanol to regular gasoline. Hydrogen, the purest and preferred source (no pesky carbon molecules to deal with) is not energy-dense at all which is why it needs to be stored highly compressed, which unforunately means a heavy metal cylinder to contain it restricting its use. I'm afraid your physics is off though. The fuel cell generates the electricity as it needs it, it's not present as potential energy, hence dropping it in the tub would do you no harm. If you want to know more about how a fuel cell works, or have any questions about them, please email me directly ptemple[at]progressivepublishing.com.
   
   Phillip.

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

3.  

   Re: Seems safe to me

   

   Phillip, Sep 6th, 2001 @ 4:17pm

   
   

   Forgot (as did the article) to also mention that there is no longer any recharge time. A quick squirt of whatever into the fuel cell and you are instantly back in business.
   
   Phillip.

   [ reply to this | link to this | view in thread ]

Add Your Comment